Why does Frank tell Rita the story of the theology student?
Frank pointed out the anecdote of the theology student to Rita to illustrate his remark: “…a clever answer is not necessarily the correct answer.” Rita had been witty when answering his previous question on her essay, but she failed to understand that in the context in which she was now immersed other parameters would be taken into consideration when deciding which mark her essay should be given. So, though her answer was not precisely incorrect, it would have meant a failure in her essay due to her not following the necessary “rules” when writing an academic paper. These rules are what Frank is going to teach her in the course of her studies since what Rita essentially needs is not content knowledge but guidance. I’m sure, she will discover the rest by herself… I found it interesting the way Frank tries to guide her train of thought, helping her to spot the connections so as to build a rich support for her essay. I must say he is very patient, and I am also sure he knows Rita has a big potential and that she has what’s needed to be an excellent student.
4 comentarios:
So...what is "needed to be an excellent student", Lu?
And how fair is it that students are not given a voice as to what is "correct" or "acceptable" at school? In terms of politics, what kind of societies does this turn schools into? Can you relate this to your idea that Frank is really "patient" with Rita's "differences"?
Tough, right? No need to rush and post back, though... Take your time!
See you in class (I hope!)
Gladys
Hi Gladys!
Yes, indeed really tough.
First of all, I consider that Rita has what is needed to be an excellent student because she has the determination to learn whatever it takes. In every aspect of life I believe we can be successful if we listen to ourselves and follow our passion.
As regards the place students´ voice have in the classroom, I believe we are always following the same model throughout the centuries. Of course, there have been changes as regards teaching and learning, but nothing revolutionary that makes the society take a step aside from the conservative point of view. I don’t know if I making myself clear…but well, I think students should have a voice in school matters.
Times are changing, and in the supposedly communication era we are more and more separated emotionally, we are becoming more and more individualistic and these changes are reflected in schools. Schools should foster communication and they should promote it by giving the opportunity to the students to express freely and to trust others.
I´m still reflecting upon this...
Maybe you're right as far as trends are concerned, Lu, but then... we are the ones who can choose what's to happen in our lessons! ;-)
Incredible power... that brings about lots of responsibility! :-P
Sleep tight!
Gladys
Publicar un comentario